Selecting the best HCP-ELISA of 5 kits

Comparing the coverage and ability to detect HCPs of concern of commercial kits

CASE STUDY

Selecting the best HCP-ELISA for use during early drug development is crucial: Suppose the chosen ELISA has insufficient coverage of host cell protein (HCP) impurities in the final product. In that case, it may result in project delays due to new assay development and purification improvements required by regulatory authorities.

Our client is an international biotech company developing antibody therapeutics for oncology treatment. They came to us, asking for a comparison of the performance of five commercial CHO kits from four suppliers.

The method applied for this study was ELISA-MS™, which combines immunocapture and mass spectrometry for HCP coverage analysis. A benefit of ELISA-MS™ is that it does not require a mock sample but works with early and complex process samples. Moreover, the method uses less than 1 mg of antibodies. This is much more cost-efficient than techniques based on affinity purification columns, which often need 10-15 mg ELISA antibodies.

HCP ELISA coverage analysis on harvest samples

To find the best ELISA kit for our client’s biologic, we analyzed the HCP content of a harvest cell culture fluid (HCCF) sample supplied by the client. We then compared the coverage of the five commercial HCP-ELISA kits. The figure below shows the coverage of each kit. As you can see, ELISA kits A, D, and E each had relatively high coverage, above 60 percent.

Comparison of Host Cell Proteins in an early process sample covered by five ELISA kits

Comparison of Host Cell Proteins in an early process sample covered by five ELISA kits

Detection of Host Cell Proteins of concern

Our client could have based their choice of ELISA kit on total HCP coverage. However, they also wanted to evaluate the kits’ ability to detect individual HCPs of concern. There were five HCPs on their watch list, and we investigated how well the five ELISAs covered them.

In the table below, green indicates a covered HCP. Our results showed that kit A had the best coverage of the five specific HCPs of concern. This information, in conjunction with the coverage percentages, allowed our client to choose the best commercial ELISA kit for their product.

Evaluation of how well five kits detected Host Cell Proteins of concern in a harvest sample
Evaluation of how well five kits detected Host Cell Proteins of concern in a harvest sample

US-based Biotech_logo
"Based on the data provided by Alphalyse, we settled on a kit that we knew provided both excellent coverage of the HCPs overall and the individual HCPs of concern"

US-based Biotech- Senior CMC specialist

Improve your protein research
Subscribe to our newsletter and get 3 tips that will instantly improve your protein analysis results

Receive monthly emails with news, tips, case stories
and offers for protein analysis
© Copyright Alphalyse 2002 - 2023. All rights reserved.