What is SWATH mass spectrometry and its advantages in HCP analysis?

What is SWATH?
Alphalyse
Jun 22. 2017

Host Cell Proteins (HCPs) in protein biopharmaceuticals can be analyzed by the mass spectrometry SWATH analysis. It provides both identification and quantification of the individual HCPs [1].

The analysis requires optimized sample preparation protocols for enzymatic protein cleavage into peptides. It also requires highly advanced liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS) techniques [2].

The major analytical challenges are:

  • Measurement of low level HCPs (nanogram amount) in the presence of mg amounts of drug substance protein.
  • Reproducibility of the MS techniques to identify and quantify each low-level HCP.

The solutions is simple; SWATH analysis by LC-MS can solve both of these challenges. This makes it an ideal tool in HCP analysis for bioprocess optimization [3].

Get free SWATH application note >>

You will find a description of the principles of LC-MS/MS of peptides and advantages of SWATH MS for HCP analysis below:

LC-MS of peptides

For LC-MS/MS of peptides several terms are important to understand

In the figure above, the term MS (or MS1) describes the analysis where the MS-instrument measures the intact mass of a peptide. The term MS/MS (or MS2) describes the analysis where you isolate a specific peptide mass (m/z) and fragment it into specific fragment ions. You can use the masses of a peptide and its fragment ions to identify the peptide. Also, you may use the intensity of the MS signals to quantify the peptide [4, 5].

What is SWATH mass spectrometry?

Source:
sciex.com

Mass spectrometers can perform MS/MS analysis in Data Dependent Acquisition mode (DDA) [3]. DDA is also sometimes referred to as Information Dependent Acquisition mode (IDA), as illustrated in the figure above.

In DDA mode, the mass spectrometer first selects the most intense peptide ions (top 10-15 peaks) in MS1. It then sends them one-by-one into the fragmentation analysis (MS2).

Experience shows that DDA analysis of a complex peptide sample generates different protein identification results for identical technical replicates. In proteomics research you commonly see reports of protein identification results when 2 out of 3 technical replicates observe a given protein. In DDA mode of a complex sample the instrument does not have enough time to select all peptides for MS/MS analysis. Instead, you only analyze the top 10-15 peptides. The instrument then decides on-the-fly which peptide to select – which creates variation from run to run [3].

Advanced mass spectrometers can also perform Data Independent Acquisition (DIA). Then they fragment all peptides within a certain mass range in MS/MS. This instrument is not selecting individual peptides, and therefore the data acquisition in DIA-mode is more reproducible [4, 5].

What is SWATH?

SWATH analysis is a special type of DIA.

In HCP SWATH mode, the Sciex mass spectrometer divides the mass range into small mass windows. Eventually, there can be up to hundreds of windows. The instrument performs MS/MS analysis on all peptides in each window. With dynamic size mass windows you will have small windows in areas with many peptides. – While larger windows in areas with few peptides [3].

“The beauty of SWATH analysis is that you can acquire mass spectrometry data for all peptides without knowing what to look for”

Interpretation of a complex HCP SWATH mass spectrum with fragmentation of multiple peptides requires comparison to an ion library with mass spectrometry data on known peptides. The ion library contains information about each peptide, including HPLC retention time, MS/MS data and amino acid sequence. The ion library can be build using DDA analysis of the samples. Furthermore, you can expand the library with new data on more samples [3].

Key advantages of HCP SWATH analysis by mass spectrometry:

  • Low interference from the high amount of the drug substance protein. Because your aquire the data on low level HCP peptides in data-independent mode in small mass windows.
  • Highly reproducible HCP identification and quantification because data are acquired in Data Independent Acquisition mode.
  • All recorded SWATH analysis data can be re-analyzed – when the ion library is updated with more known compounds and their fragmentation pattern.

See examples of HCP SWATH analysis for biopharmaceutical proteins and bioprocess sample >>

Download our application note for a description of Alphalyse’s HCP analysis based on SWATH LC-MS >>

What is SWATH?

Get free SWATH application note >>

References:

[1]          Wang et al: “Host Cell Proteins in Biologics Development: Identification, Quantitation and Risk Assessment“, Biotechnology and Bioengineering, 2009

[2]          Bracewell et al: “The Future of Host Cell Protein (HCP) Identification During Process Development and Manufacturing Linked to a Risk-Based Management for Their Control“, Biotechnology and Bioengineering2015

[3]          Heissel et al: Evaluation of spectral libraries and sample preparation for DIA-LC-MS analysis of host cell proteins: A case study of a bacterially expressed recombinant biopharmaceutical protein”, Protein Expression and Purification2018

[4]          Doerr, A.: “DIA mass spectrometry“, Nature Methods, 2015

[5]          Law et al: “Recent advances in mass spectrometry: data independent analysis and hyper reaction monitoring“, Expert Review of Proteomics”2013

More posts about Analysis of Biopharmaceuticals
  • Host Cell Protein monitoring in process development – using mass spec

  • Analysis method for Mw HCPs (small HCPs) below 20 kDa

    Identification of small host cell proteins (small Mw HCPs)

  • Extinction coefficient protein concentration

    Determine the Molar Extinction Coefficient of protein in 3 small steps

  • Why you need accurate concentration determination of protein standards

  • Why disulfide bridges are critical quality attributes of biologics

About Alphalyse

Alphalyse uses expertise in the field of protein chemistry and bioinformatics, combined with top-of-the-line mass spectrometry equipment, to provide protein analysis services globally.

Alphalyse aims to deliver high quality data and customer service to all of our clients in a fast and convenient way.

www.alphalyse.com

Newsletter Subscribe to The Alphalyse Newsletter and get more
information on protein analysis methods and applications
© 2021 Alphalyse, Inc.